Leave the clan, lose your exp. Simple.

I'm bored of people leaving and then re-joining when they fancy. This isn't the first time Meg has left and re-joined within a short period of time.

(click to show/hide)

Quote from: Happi on September 02, 2014, 00:02:43

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:58:07

Quote from: Happi on September 01, 2014, 23:56:07

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:38:44

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

When did she joined? In the end of the month, it looks pretty clear to me.

She was in the end for the entire duration of the month and had gained almost 73m exp in that time. So where's that gone? or are we just going to disregard her work during the month?

Its just how it works on the runescape website clan thing isn't it?
Why should it be different here?
If someone leaves a clan during the clan cup competion and decides to rejoin do you think jagex will keep the exp that person had on a little desktop note waiting for the person to join back to keep tracking from where the person was?
Why should we?

It is pretty clear to me on the rules and I'll quote them again.

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:38:44

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

New rule as of May 2013
Pro & Noob will now only be for in-game ranked members.

Loses her rank on the cc all the progress is gone since its not a member anymore.
Joins the clan as a new member starts to be tracked.

Is that hard to understand?

the only thing the clan lost when Meg left was a ton of clan xp (300m-400m+) and got pushed further down the rankings, she left for ~10 hours and the tracker has maybe 500k exp on it that does not count. There was no rule in place stating "If you leave during the month and rejoin your exp gets wiped", sure it can get put in after this situation but it's unfair that it's being implemented on the spot, it's just silly and makes no sense, and is disrespectful to meg who put in the most effort for exp to help the clan out. Guess leaving and making that xp go away is a tough loss 

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

New rule as of May 2013
Pro & Noob will now only be for in-game ranked members.

No rules were created for this situation and I know by reading this two rules you can clearly understand why she lost her exp Runar.
Her monthly exp was tracked from the most recent join date, it says on second rule that only ranked members will be tracked, she was not a member at some point stopped being tracked, joined the clan during the month started to get tracked as it says on the first rule.
We'd have a bible of rules if people can't read two of them and understand how they work in conjunction.

Quote from: Runar on September 02, 2014, 00:19:46

(click to show/hide)

Quote from: Happi on September 02, 2014, 00:02:43

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:58:07

Quote from: Happi on September 01, 2014, 23:56:07

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:38:44

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

When did she joined? In the end of the month, it looks pretty clear to me.

She was in the end for the entire duration of the month and had gained almost 73m exp in that time. So where's that gone? or are we just going to disregard her work during the month?

Its just how it works on the runescape website clan thing isn't it?
Why should it be different here?
If someone leaves a clan during the clan cup competion and decides to rejoin do you think jagex will keep the exp that person had on a little desktop note waiting for the person to join back to keep tracking from where the person was?
Why should we?

It is pretty clear to me on the rules and I'll quote them again.

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:38:44

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

New rule as of May 2013
Pro & Noob will now only be for in-game ranked members.

Loses her rank on the cc all the progress is gone since its not a member anymore.
Joins the clan as a new member starts to be tracked.

Is that hard to understand?

the only thing the clan lost when Meg left was a ton of clan xp (300m-400m+) and got pushed further down the rankings, she left for ~10 hours and the tracker has maybe 500k exp on it that does not count. There was no rule in place stating "If you leave during the month and rejoin your exp gets wiped", sure it can get put in after this situation but it's unfair that it's being implemented on the spot, it's just silly and makes no sense, and is disrespectful to meg who put in the most effort for exp to help the clan out. Guess leaving and making that xp go away is a tough loss 

Quote from: Alan on September 01, 2014, 23:38:44

User's joining the clan during a month that's already being tracked will be added to the tracker but they will obviously be at a major disadvantage.

New rule as of May 2013
Pro & Noob will now only be for in-game ranked members.

No rules were created for this situation and I know by reading this two rules you can clearly understand why she lost her exp Runar.
Her monthly exp was tracked from the most recent join date, it says on second rule that only ranked members will be tracked, she was not a member at some point stopped being tracked, joined the clan during the month started to get tracked as it says on the first rule.
We'd have a bible of rules if people can't read two of them and understand how they work in conjunction.

She left after a petty argument, she rejoined less than a day later, the rule does not state that if you leave the clan at the end of the month your exp stops tracking, or gets wiped. If the rule stated that, I would agree with it.
She gained 73M exp, she left on the 29th of august, basically the 3rd last day of the entire month, and rejoined the very next day. It's really lame to see people denying the fact Meg won this month's pro and noob considering it's a harmless/pointless competition that should not stir this much up, but it clearly does because the people hosting it refuse to abide by their own rules.

Why does everything always lead to some argument on the forum, I make the news to be positive for the clan and it's hijacked by this whole pathetic conversation.

Enjoy the read, I'm locking.

This is unlocked please keep focused on the news  it's to thank the staff member who created the news and to
Congratulate members on their achievements.

Any off topic posts will be removed.

Thanks once again on the news josh.

Interesting read Josh, thanks! Quite a lot of Thieving this month to lol!

Well done everyone on their achievments to!

Great read as always, thats for sure
Congrats to all on their achievements and Ranks ups.


Scumbag out, Peace.

Thanks Josh! finally saw your edition of the clan news

Grats everyone on your achievements & well done!

Why does everything always lead to some argument on the forum, I make the news to be positive for the clan and it's hijacked by this whole pathetic conversation.

Enjoy the read, I'm locking.

Sorry there mate didn't intended to hijack your work
I enjoyed reading the news well done Josh

Thanks for the news Josh Wanted to say it earlier buy yanoo

You are all welcome

Well done with the news, and Congrats to everyone who is relevant.